|
Packaging - ***
The box does it's most important job well - the dense foam trays keep
the statue safe and sound. There's no window, and there's no COA, but
the edition size and number are printed on the bottom of the box and
bottom of the stand as well.
Sculpting - ** This is a very low sculpting score from me for any statue in this series, and there's one reason and one reason only for it. It's
not the overall work by Shoop. He's captured the look of Daniel's work
in three dimensions, and done it with strong lines and appropriate
proportions. Some of the sculpt has a slightly rough appearance to it,
but that's Shoop's style. It's also not the pose, though I have
to admit that it's not my favorite. The 'landing from a jump' pose is
starting to get a bit played in the Black and White series. It's
alright here though, and the swooping C shape of the overall body is
visually pleasing. Nope, the reason I'm scoring this guy so low
is a manufacturing and/or design issue. There are two metal pegs, one
on the front foot, and one on the bottom of the longest, thickest piece
of cape. These two posts should fit into the two holes on
the base. But they do not line up properly, and to get him in place
you'll have to put pressure on the resin. That's not good - it's very
easy to break the foot or the cape when forcing the metal posts. Or you
could do what I did - I scratched the paint on the base trying to get
the posts to fit. That's unacceptable with a collectible like
this, and is a critical quality issue. I bet there's a lot of returns
and breakage on this statue due to this problem. These statues are in that 6 - 7" scale, and this guy tends toward the larger end of that range, with an overall height of 9".
Paint - ***
There's a few sloppy edges, especially around the boots and gloves.
There's also a little clumpiness to some of the coverage, which pulls
the score down slightly. It's
worth noting that this is an unusual color for a black and white
statue. You expect gray scale of course, but generally there's been a
lot of true black as well. Here, there's very little, and the darker
gray is not quite gray. I'm not sure what it is, but my eyes are
telling me there's some purple in the gray...your eyes might tell you
different, but it's not a pure gray scale. They did use some different finishes from matte to gloss to set various parts of the uniform apart.
Value - **1/2
I ranking this guy at about $70, which is about average considering
other statues and busts in this scale on the market. If you manage to
grab him for around $60, you can add another half star here.
Things to Watch Out For -
I'm assuming everyone will have the issue with the pegs not quite
lining up with the holes. Since the pegs are steel, and the foot and
cape are resin, forcing them can easily break the statue. Be VERY VERY
careful attaching the statue to the base.
Overall - **1/2
If this statue had not had the issue with the steel posts and their
misalignment, this statue would have scored much better overall. But
there's really no excuse for such a critical quality flaw to make it
through production, and this is the sort of issue that's likely to
be consistent across the run.
Score Recap:
Packaging - ***
Sculpting - **
Paint - ***
Value - **1/2
Overall - **1/2
Where to Buy -
Online options include these site sponsors:
- Fanboy Collectibles has it for $60. - Urban
Collector has him for $63. - Mike's
Comics N Stuff has it for $68. - Big Bad Toy Store has him at $70.
- Things From Another World has it for $72.
- Capstone Comics has him at $72.
- Entertainment
Earth has him at $73. - or you can search
ebay for a deal.
Related
Links -
Lots of Batman Black and white reviews: - the last was Arkham Asylum. - back before the holidays, I looked at the cool
Man-bat.
- before that, we had the Quitely version of
Batman, the Bermejo, the McGuinness
version, the Dave Mazzucchelli
version, the Penguin, Gotham Knight 2 version, the Bruce Timm version, the Ethan Van Sciver version, the Aparo, the Neal Adams and George Perez versions, the Gotham Knight, Bob
Kane, Frank Miller, Jim Lee, Matt
Wagner, Mike Mignola, and Kelley Jones. *whew* Discussion:
Want to chat about this
review? Try out one of these terrific
forums where I'll be
discussing it!
Enjoyed this review? Be sure to head back to the main page to find
thousands more just like it! |