|
Packaging - Mayan ***;
Grave/Tech *1/2
The boxes for the Grave Danger set and the Tech Savvy set are quite
basic, designed to just get the diorama safely to your door. No
graphics or text, with those damn cheap styrofoam inserts too.
The Mayan version actually adds
in some graphics and text, garnering it a bit better score here.
Instead of styrofoam, there's a plastic insert holding the
pieces.
Of
course, all these boxes fit the definition of 'collector friendly',
since you don't destroy anything getting the pieces out and you can
always
put them back later if you so desire.
Sculpting - Grave,
Mayan ***1/2; Tech ***
You'll notice
that there is a distinct price difference between the Mayan base and
the other two - a good 40% difference. If you were thinking it was a
size thing, let me assure you it's not. And let me save you the trouble
by adding "That's what she said". While the Grave Danger and Tech Savvy
sets are slightly taller (Mayan is about 12", while Grave Danger is 14"
and Tech Savvy is about 13 1/2"), the round base is slightly bigger on
the Mayan. It's roughly 10" in diameter while the other two are about
9" square.
So why the cost difference?
Materials. The taller two
are polyresin, like most statues and busts. These tend to take a
sharper, more detailed sculpt, but tend to cost more as well - and they
do break if you drop them. The slightly shorter Mayan base is hollow
ABS plastic. This feels cheaper when you pick it up - it lacks the heft
of the other two - but there's no fear of damage, even if you drop it.
The
sculpt on all three, including the plastic Mayan, is very detailed and
quite sharply cut. Bricks, stone, pipes, etc. are all clearly defined,
and quite realistic.
Assembly with the two resin sets
was a bit tricky, due to the major
pieces (back, bottom) not matching up as well as they should. Don't
force it! You will break the 'tabs' on the bottom and back if you apply
too much pressure.
Paint - ***1/2
All three pieces have realistically painted surfaces, emulating the
look of stone and dirt. The stain and dirt patterns give the dioramas
an eerie, ancient look, while the paint work on areas like the pipes
gives the impression of metal.
While
I think the stone effect on both the Grave Danger and Mayan sets is
pitch perfect, there does seem to be something slightly off about the
coloration and style of the cement block wall of the Tech Savvy base.
It's not a major problem, and the smaller detail work on this set makes
up for it, but still worth noting.
Design/Quality - ***1/2
Considering the price point and the extremely low production runs, the
quality is top notch.
The
resin sets are quite heavy, and the pieces are all solid and well
built. The plastic Mayan set will feel cheaper when you pick it up, but
don't forget that it IS cheaper - by $30!
All three sets work with sixth
scale figures, but they also have plenty of potential with slightly
smaller scales.
I
already mentioned my minor complaint on assembly with the Grave Danger
and Tech Savvy sets, but it's worth noting again here. While I finally
was able to get the Grave Danger back completely in place, I'm still
unable to get theTech Savvy set quite right. It'll hold, but it's not
completely together.
The
Mayan base has two posts with special tabs to lock in place, and that
worked without a hitch. It also has a small yellow 'jewel' at the
center of the backdrop that adds just the right amount of color and
bling.
Other assembly, like adding the
gravestone and bat-wing
bust to the Grave Danger set, works great. The large pipe on the Tech
Savvy wall also comes as a separate piece, and snaps in place tightly.
I ended up super gluing it there (and I may do the same with the
gravestone) just to avoid forgetting that it can come loose and
dropping it in the future.
From a design perspective it's
important to note that these can serve many needs. The Mayan set
obviously works best for an Indy or a Lara Croft, but I think putting
He-man in front of it works great too. The Grave Danger set is perfect
for your zombies or other horror characters, and if you leave the grave
marker off, it can be used as a military figure backdrop. And the Tech
Savvy wall is ideal for Freddy, but could work with just about any
superhero or sci-fi character. If you'd like to expand on the Tech
Savvy set, there's a B
version that has a slightly different arrangement of piping
and valves.
Value - Mayan ***1/2;
Grave Danger, Tech Savvy ***
All three of these bases are quite large, and have terrific sculpting
and paint. While the Mayan is plastic instead of resin, until you pick
it up you won't realize it, and it's a whopping 40% cheaper than the
other two. But even those two are just $70, a full $20
cheaper
than the same type of resin diorama offering from Sideshow.
These
are an excellent value in the current market, and well worth picking up
at this price.
Things to Watch Out For -
Be very careful assembling the two resin sets. Don't force anything!
Overall - ***1/2
Once in awhile, something comes along
that really surprises me. I had no idea Triad was working on these
until they sent me the Grave Danger set. As soon as I had it open, I
zipped over to their site to see what else was available, and bought
the Mayan and Tech Savvy sets in a heartbeat. I'm very happy with all
three right now, and I plan on picking up any future releases as
well.
As to the plastic vs. resin
debate, I have to say
that while I love the heft of the resin, I'd be just as happy if they
stuck with the ABS plastic. At just $40, the Mayan base is a terrific
value, and gets you the most bang for your buck. I've seen others use a
polyurethane type material too, and that can look terrific and keep
costs down as well. I think Triad is on the right track here, and I
hope we see them expand on the concept.
Score Recap:
Packaging - Mayan ***;
Grave/Tech *1/2
Sculpting - Grave, Mayan ***1/2; Tech ***
Paint - ***1/2
Design/Quality - ***1/2
Value - Mayan ***1/2; Grave, Tech ***
Overall - ***1/2
Where to Buy -
Online options include these site sponsors:
- you can pick these up right
from Triad of course: the Mayan
is $40, the Grave
Danger is $70, and the Tech
Savvy is $70.
- your other best option is to watch
ebay for a deal.
Related
Links -
Other sixth scale dioramas include:
- Sideshow's Recon at Waypoint (for
Joes, mostly).
- Sideshow's Reactor Station Alpha.
- other more license specific
environments include Hot Toys T-700,
the Ark that came with Sideshow's Toht, the
Fertility
Idol environment that came with Belloq the Jabba
Throne, as well as the Han
Solo in Carbonite.
- and if you want to get a bit
more old school, don't forget the Freddy
Kruger furnace Sideshow did years ago.
- and in the 8" scale, there's
the nifty Phantom's
Throne.
Discussion:
Want to chat about this
review? Try out one of these terrific
forums where I'll be
discussing it!
Enjoyed this review? Be sure to head back to the main page to find
thousands more just like it!
KEEP SCROLLING DOWN FOR LOTS MORE
PHOTOS!
|