Sculpting - ***1/2
There's not much to complain about when it comes to the sculpting here. there's no real portrait, but the armor looks fantastic. Now,
I suspect that some fans will find issues with something - some aspect
of the helmet that isn't quite screen exact, some piece of the armor
that's not quite in scale. But I gotta say that I think it looks
terrific, and I have no serious complaints. The pelvic armor is a
bit tight, which makes the hips look a little weird (and would be
awfully uncomfortable), but that's a minor nit. Unless you're the poor
sucker wearing this stuff.
Paint - ****
While the white armor is cast in the proper color, the green striping
is obviously added, and added well. But it's not the show room
perfection of this detailing that makes it look good - it's the damage
and wear. They've done a terrific job of adding in scuffs, wear marks,
scratches, and discoloration in appropriate places. This adds a
tremendous amount of realism to the figure, and gives him the feel of a
battle tested soldier.
Articulation - ***1/2
The underlying body is the standard Sideshow sixth scale version that
they developed a couple years ago. It's not quite TrueType level, but
it's a huge improvement over their previous body, and it works well
enough for Troopers like these. There's
all the usual joints, ball, cut, pin, etc. You know what's here, and
the joints are tighter and smoother than the first few releases. The
figure includes some 'action' feet, and you can pull off poses with
these because the ankles, knees and hips are tight enough to hold weird
poses. They aren't quite as tight as some similar bodies, but they work
well enough. You can get some fairly natural stances, although
again, it's not quite at the TrueType level. Some folks may feel the
need to swap these over, but it's not necessary.
Accessories - ****
This guy comes with a TON of extra hands, done up in some really nifty poses. There
are a total of thirteen hands, including the two he comes wearing.
There's a set of gun gripping hands, a set of soft gripping hands, a
set of fists, a set of hands in a "STOP" pose (or perhaps a salute), a
set of thumbs up, a set of pointing hands (one pointing with one
finger, the other pointing with two fingers), and one single hand that
is posed in a peace sign, two fingers up in the flying V. The
hands swap easily enough, but be careful with the posts. You should
free them up before you put them on, but go easy on the pegs. They can
snap with too much pressure. All the hands have their own pegs and ball
joints, so you don't have to keep swapping them on the actual joint.
That's a much appreciated addition. There's also a second set of
feet. The front half of the foot is bent, perfect for some action
poses. They swap as easily as the hands, but the same caution should be
taken when adjusting the posts. There are the two blasters that
we've seen before, long rifle and short. The short has the folding
stock, and both fit great in the gripping hands. The scale is
excellent, as is the paint and sculpt. Finally, there's the usual
display stand. You shouldn't need it, but for those that prefer to keep
them safely secured on the shelf, the consistent stands are a nice
touch.
Outfit - ***1/2
Underlying the Clone Trooper armor is the ribbed black stretch costume.
It fits tightly, and looks pretty close to screen accurate. It's not
exactly how the costume was done, but the approximation works for me. The
various pieces of armor are made from a solid, hard plastic, nothing
rubbery here. The pieces fit well, and the sculpt looks great. The
chest piece seems to ride a little high, but everything else looks
terrific - well, it would if you weren't an idiot like me and you don't
forget to turn the bicep armor around. I didn't even notice til after
I'd edited all the photos, but I'm warning you not to make the same
mistake. The calf armor was also turned around on mine in the package,
but that I was smart enough to notice.
Fun Factor - ***
The armor and accessories are quite sturdy, certainly as sturdy as what
we see with mass market toys. It's surprising, but while these are
probably out of the price range for most folks to buy them for kids,
they could be great toys. Perhaps that's what makes them such great
collectibles too - they haven't lost sight of the tradition of their
ancestors.
Value - ***
At around $80, these are actually a pretty good deal. That's not too
far off from the price getting charged by some of the smaller sixth
scale figure companies, who use far inferior bodies. Obviously, the
body and armor re-use across multiple figures helps keep these down in
cost, but it's still a good value for the Star Wars fan.
Things to Watch Out For -
I mentioned the stiff pegs - be sure you work them lose a bit before
putting the hands on, and take really care with them. Otherwise, you
should be good to go!
Overall - ***1/2
Another great trooper for the shelf. It's hard to get excited about
another Clone Trooper when we've already got a boat load, but Sideshow
knew they'd need to up the ante, and that's where the ton of hands and
extra feet come into play. The underlying body could still be a hair
better, but fans of the Troopers should be pleased with the addition to
the collection.
Score Recap:
Packaging - ****
Sculpting - ***1/2
Paint - ****
Articulation - ***1/2
Accessories - ****
Outfit - ***1/2
Fun Factor - ***
Value - ***
Overall - ***1/2
Where to Buy -
Online options include these site sponsors:
- Alter Ego Comics
has the Sarge for $81.
- or you can search
ebay for a deal.
Related
Links -
Other sixth scale Sideshow Star Wars include:
- last up was the dimunitive
Jedi, Yoda.
- I also liked the recent Gammorean Guard.
- it was awhile before that for
the previous review, Admiral
Thrawn and his command chair.
- prior to that was Lando
Calrissian, and the Shock
Trooper.
- Darth Vader was perhaps
Sideshow's best Star Wars release.
- then there's the Utapau Trooper, the
Imperial Stormtrooper,
and Captain Antilles.
- I wasn't as thrilled with Ki-Adi-Mundi, but Obi-Wan in Clone Armor
is easily one of their best. Then there's Aayla Secura, Tatooine Luke and Han Solo.
- Sideshow had a strong year in
2008 with Commander Praji,
the exceptional Palpatine/Sidous
and ANH Obi-Wan,
and the not quite so exceptional Ilum
Padme.
- also in the sixth scale line,
I've reviewed Leia and
Bespin Luke, the Holo-chess
set, Sideshow's
Asajj, a terrific figure, Yavin
Luke, the Endor
Troops, Jabba the
Hutt and his
throne, Bib Fortuna,
Jedi
Luke, Darth Maul,
Obi-Wan,
Bespin
Han Solo, regular Anakin
Skywalker and Kit
Fisto.
- I also have guest reviews of
the SDCC Anakin Skywalker,
Mace
Windu, Emperor
Palpatine and his throne, and Qui-Gon
Jinn.
- in the premium format line,
I've reviewed Darth Talon,
Jedi
Luke, Yoda with
the Clone Trooper, Slave
Leia, Darth Vader,
Princess
Leia, Boba Fett,
Obi-Wan
Kenobi, and Han
Solo.
Discussion:
Want to chat about this
review? Try out one of these terrific
forums where I'll be
discussing it!
Enjoyed this review? Be sure to head back to the main page to find
thousands more just like it!
KEEP
SCROLLING DOWN FOR MORE
PHOTOS!
|