|
Packaging - ***
The box is fairly attractive, and has a big plus at this price point -
it's collector friendly. That means you can remove the inside tray, pop
out the figures (no twisty ties or rubber bands at all!), and put them
back clean and neat without any real damage to the box. The
box doesn't say Raiders of the Lost Ark, but that's what this set is
clearly based on. It does mention a 3+ age range though, which is
appropriate considering the quality and price.
Sculpting - Cairo Swordsman, German ***; Sallah **1/2; Indy **; Marion * From
past Disney releases, we know they don't have the movie likeness
rights, particularly for Indy himself. So it's no surprise that Indiana
Jones looks a bit more like Basketball Jones,
his distant cousin. The Indy body pose is decent for an action stance,
but the goofy grin and oversized hands takes a bit off his score. Marion
is an utter disaster, and will end up on my worst of 201 list, no doubt
about it. With her horsey face and completely unworkable pose, she'll
be tossed into the bin the moment she's free from the tray. Sallah
has a fairly good sculpt, especially when it comes to a realistic
facial sculpt in this scale. The paint doesn't do much to let it shine,
but the work on the portrait is nice - too bad the oversized hands
kills it. The Cairo Swordsman and German Mechanic are the winners
of the set. Both have very good sculpts that we can appreciate as
much as the weak paint ops will allow. The Swordsman has a few
problems staying upright, but the German stood tall for me without any
trouble. Both have properly sized heads and hands as well, something
that Sallah and Indy lack. These figures are all just under 4" tall, and can work pretty well scale-wise with other 3 3/4" - 4" series.
Paint - **
While the sculpting on three of the five is reasonable, the paint is simply awful all the way around. The
mechanic has this very dark red lower lip, thick and wide. I'm assuming
that they were going for a bloody look here, after Indy had punched
him. I give them some credit for trying, but it looks awful, and
nothing like a bloody mouth. Instead, it looks like he has a reverse
double mustache, or some weird skin condition. The rest of the
figures all have a lot of slop, fuzzy cut lines, and poor definition.
The skin tone on the hands is clumpy, and most of the hairlines are
poorly defined. There's a few details here and there, but most of the
paint work is broad and sweeping, covering large chunks of plastic.
They did work with a wash on some of the clothing to add wear and dirt,
and this works a bit better than expected. While there's really
no saving Marion, slightly better paint ops would have greatly improved
the German, Sallah and the Swordsman.
Articulation - *
There ain't much. All the figures have some sort of arm articulation.
For most it's a cut shoulder, but for the Cairo Swordsman it's cut
joints where the arms meet the robes. And that's it. There are a few spots that *look* like joints (like the neck and waist of the German Mechanic), but sadly these are glued tight. With
this woefully inadequate articulation, it's probably no surprise that
many of the figures have a tough time standing. The German had the
least amount of trouble, while it's impossible to keep Marion on her
feet without support. The others fall somewhere in between, and will
probably require a quick dip in hot water, some bending of the feet,
and a quick dip in the cold to repose them slightly and make standing
an easier task. Poor Marion is a lost cause.
Accessories - ***
There are several, and one in particular saves the set from a lower score. There's
the small handgun for Indy, which can't go in the holster but does fit
in his sculpted left hand. His whip is NOT an accessory, as it is
firmly glued permanently in place. There's a torch for Sallah,
which also fits in in his left hand. The torch sculpt and paint work is
on par with most of the figures, which means it's pretty weak. There's also a small Fertility Idol, which has the best sculpt and paint of the little accessories. The
frying pan in Marion's hand and the sword in the Cairo Swordsman's grip
are both like Indy's whip - permanently attached. Therefore neither
count toward this score. If it were just those three, they'd be
getting closer to ** here, maybe less, but they've also included a
fairly accurate (for this scale and price point) Ark of the Covenant.
The Ark opens, and has a very nice sculpt and paint job. The poles were
bent a bit by the plastic tray, but with a hot and cold water treatment
you should be able to correct that. Open it up, and the interior is
painted a sand color - it even has tassels!
Fun Factor - ***
While the sculpts and paint are weak, these are still pretty good toys
- and at a good price. If the German ends up under the lawn mower, you
won't be crying about the loss. In
fact, these would have received a full four star score here had they
not had trouble standing. Kids find that to be very frustrating when
they are trying to play out battles and scenes - nobody wants to spend
five minutes standing up a figure just to knock him down.
Value - ***1/2
To buy 5 figures in this scale at your local store would cost you at
least $30. For some series, like Star Wars, that's more like $40. This
full set is just $13 at the Disney store, which is quite the bargain.
Of course, these figures don't have the articulation, accessories and
overall quality of something like a new Hasbro Star Wars figure, making
the price not quite the bargain it could be. Still, if you're looking
for some Indy toys for your son or daughter, this set is a much better
value.
Things to Watch Out For -
Not a thing.
Overall - **
Honestly, these aren't good figures. Almost no articulation, weak
paint, only passable sculpting on some and terrible on others...these
aren't going in too many 'collector' displays. I
will say that with a little paint work, the German Mechanic might be a
good fit with the Hasbro line, and you could always toss the Cairo
Swordsman and Sallah in for giggles. But if you're looking for a
set of figures that a smaller child - say 5 or 6 up to around 10 -
could get a ton of play out of, and won't cost you big bucks, then
these are perfect. Kids that enjoyed the Hasbro line might like adding
these guys into the mix, and the Ark is certainly a well done accessory
for the scale.
Score Recap:
Packaging - ***
Sculpting - Cairo Swordsman, German ***; Sallah **1/2; Indy **; Marion *
Paint - **
Articulation - *
Accessories - ***
Fun Factor - ***
Value - ***1/2
Overall - **
Where to Buy - These guys are exclusive to the Disney stores, but if you don't have one handy you can always try ebay. Related
Links - I've looked at lots of Indy product. They include: - if you're looking for something a bit more high end, check out the Indiana Jones or Mola Ram Premium Format statues from Sideshow. - they also did the exceptional Fertility Idol, but DST has a cheaper yet also awesome version. - other characters as Indy include the big Mickey, as well as Kermit.
- other figures include Sideshow's Indy and Fridge, the excellent Professor Jones Sr, the German Outfit
Indy, Toht (with Ark), Belloq with the Fertility Idol Environment, and ROTLA Indy himself.
- Medicom has released Dr. Henry Jones as
well, and Young Indy. - also in approximately this same scale is the Kotobukiya Henry Jones Sr. statue. - and Hasbro did several figures, including Indy in
German Disguise, Cairo Swordsman and German
Soldier, and two versions of Indy. Discussion:
Want to chat about this
review? Try out one of these terrific
forums where I'll be
discussing it!
Enjoyed this review? Be sure to head back to the main page to find
thousands more just like it!
|