SEARCH REVIEWS    LIVING WITH LATE FEES    FEATURES    LINKS    BIO    MISSION    EMAIL    MAIN PAGE >


Barbie Twilight Edward
Mattel

Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel

   "The following is a guest review.  The review and photos do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Michael Crawford or Michael's Review of the Week, and are the opinion and work of the guest author."

Sometime, people assume I buy anything and everything. Especially my wife. But the truth is there are some collectibles I tend to stay very far away from. Case in point - anything to do with Twilight. Don't get me wrong, I don't actually like or hate the property. I've never read the books, and I've never seen the films, so I have no opinion either way. But the appeal just isn't there for me - I'm more of a Sookie kind of guy. Thankfully, that's where guest reviewers can really help. My buddy Travis is back tonight with a guest review of the new Barbie Twilight Edward doll (or action figure, if you go by my definition). Tell us all about him, Travis!

Thanks to Michael, I'm back for my Fourth guest review! I dropped off the map for a while, but that's what happens when you live the life of a nomad like some vampire from a Stephenie Meyer novel. Ok, not really, but speaking of Vampires, Stephenie Meyer and novels, this review is of the new Edward Cullen 12"
Barbie doll. As everyone who doesn't live under a rock already knows: Twilight is the movie based on the first book from Meyer's Vampire series. The story is a simple one: Girl moves to rainy, cloudy Washington town called Forks, meets a handsome boy with a secret and they fall hopelessly in love. Oh, did I mention that his secret is he's a vampire who'd love nothing more than to eat her? I guess that's the original way Romeo and Juliet was supposed to end, but at the last minute Shakespeare decided against it.

I'm a Twilight fan and love everything about it. I don't have a problem admitting it either. Most people I talk to about Twilight hate something about it, be it the actors, special effects, etc., but I don't have a problem with anything involved. I'm looking forward to the next movie and have already picked up the New Moon action figures made by NECA, which I also recommend.
Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel

Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel
Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel
Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel
Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel
Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel
Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel

Tonight, I found this Edward doll, along with the Bella Swan Barbie at Toys R Us and promptly bought him. I could only afford one, so I waited on Bella since Edward is my favourite character. Let's see if I like him more or less after he's open. "Will the Lion fall in love with the Lamb?" Read on and find out...

Oh, and always, I apologize in advance for the cruddy photos.


Packaging - ***
The package is very nicely done and the background looks quite believable.

In fact, every time I see the moss on the tree, I keep thinking it's that fake moss stuff you can buy at any hobby shop, but it's just a photo. The "tree" is actually a nice 3-D curved piece of thin cardboard. The package itself is basically a clear plastic box with the Twilight logo printed on it in silver and the doll looks great on the shelf and stood out nicely while keeping the Twilight movie look. The back of the package sports a photo of Robert Pattinson as Edward and has a short blurb about the franchise.

The only negative thing I can say about the packaging is the following: I've bought my share of Barbie dolls over the years and they are a b*tch (no pun intended) to remove from the packages. It's almost like they aren't meant to be opened...EVER! I know they do that to "pose" the doll in a way that shows it off and make people see it in all it's glory, but sometimes it feels like you're actually destroying the doll as you open it. Add to that, the fact they never look as good in the package after you open it and replace them. I wish they were a bit more collector friendly.

Sculpting - ***
Ok, this is not Hot Toys quality and it shouldn't be for the price, so it's unfair to make comparisons that way. (Speaking of which, I wish Hot Toys would get the Twilight license, but this Mattel version will work in the
meantime.) The sculpting in this category include the head, torso and hands. The headsculpt is unlike the Bella doll in one way: Bella looks like a Barbie doll in the face and Edward doesn't look like Ken in any way, unlike, for an example, the James Bond dolls. His headsculpt is made of soft rubber and looks like a characture of Robert Pattinson and that's good enough for me. (On a side note, it's pretty close to the photos I've seen of the Tonner version of Edward, but having never seen the Tonner in person I can't really make many comparisons there either.) 

Edward's hair is rooted and spiked up and works for the character quite well. All of his features are Pattinson-esqe, like his jaw line and flat nose and I'm pretty sure people will have no doubt who the doll is supposed to be. His torso is sculpted with a six pack and looks more ripped than the average male. No wonder girls like Ken so much.

The doll stands around 12" tall.

Paint - ****
The paint is your typical Barbie fare and include his eyes, eyebrows, lips and sideburns. All done with crisp detail. The doll is actually molded in a pale lighter skin which fits his vampire lifestyle. The eyes appear to be slightly reflective in the brown/gold area, but speaking of reflective, it's another area that adds to the overall appeal of the doll. Anyone who's seen the movie or read the novels know that Edward's skin appears to be coated in diamonds whenever he's in sunlight and it actually sparkles. Well, going the extra mile in my opinion, Mattel has covered the head, neck and chest in small glitter sparkles in the plastic. It is a very nice effect and looks great. Sorry if it doesn't show up well in the photos, but it's there.

Articulation - *** 
The body appears at first glance to be a typical jointed Ken doll, although his legs and body appear more lanky than I remember the Ken dolls being.

Without being able to strip the doll down, I can only grope the doll as best I can. (yes, I realize what this sounds like.) The body appears to have limited articulation at the shoulders, neck and 870-upper legs. It's really hard to tell, but it appears to have sculpted muscles under the sleeves and pant legs exclusive to this figure and unlike anything I've seen with any other boy Barbie dolls. It seems to be a dressed action figure more than a doll.

Accessories - **
The only accessory is a doll stand, but it's a welcome addition. It has the Twilight logo printed on it and looks great. Oh, and there's a Certificate of Authenticity saying that the Edward doll is a Pink Label collectable. The labels include Pink, Silver, Gold, and Platinum. Basically, the Pink's aren't limited in production and shouldn't be hard to find.

Outfit - ***1/2
Edward's outfit is his most iconic from the first film and is very nicely made. The outfit consists of his Grey Pea coat, blue and white striped, long-sleeved shirt, black jeans and black shoes. All of the pieces are great looking and made with quality material. It would've gotten a four star rating, but strangely missing is the one piece of Edward's outfit that I like the most: his family crest Wristband. I wonder how they could've forgotten about that and wouldn't be surprised if they corrected that mistake in later waves.

Fun Factor - ****
What kid wouldn't want a handsome immortal Vampire to pay a visit to Barbie's dream house once in a while? I pretty sure a lot of little girls would want to add an Edward Cullen doll to their collection and since he seems a bit more action figure than doll, maybe other collectors would want one too. I know I did and I'm happy with him. It won't be everyone's cup of tea, but the people that want one shouldn't be dissatisfied.

Value - ****
A 12" collector figure or doll for only $24.99? Am I in the Bizarro Universe? I've gotten so used to buying $100+ figures that something like this seems so...odd. Sure the sculpt isn't anything special compared to the latest Hot Toys figures, but for a fraction of the cost, can you really complain if you still get a character you like in 12" form? I'm not: four stars!

Things to Watch Out For -
I'd take care removing him from the package and I'd think twice about removing the little plastic tabs that stitch the clothes together, since they'll probably never hang properly without them, but that's up to the person buying it. Oh, and be careful with his hair if you want it to keep it's styled look.

Overall - ***1/2
This figure is nicely made, looks great, cost little and filled the "lack of an 12" Edward Cullen figure" void in my figure shelf, which was something I've been waiting to do. This doll could've turned out to be more of an Edward/Ken amalgam instead of just a full on Edward and I'm very happy with the results. I have plans to get a Bella the next time I see her, so I must be happy with the Edward doll. Aside from the aforementioned missing wristband, I have nothing bad to say about the doll in the least.

Scoring Recap:
Packaging - ***
Sculpting - ***
Paint - ****
Articulation - ***
Accessories - **
Outfit - ***1/2
Fun Factor - ****
Value - ****
Overall - ***1/2

Where to Buy -
This one came from Toys R Us where they had two of each. (Bella and Edward) Thanks again, Michael!
Until next time, folks: Same Bat Time, Same Bat Channel! ^_^


Twilight Edward Barbie doll by Mattel


Figures from the collection of Travis

This page copyright 2000 - 2008, Michael Crawford. All rights reserved. Hosted by 1 Hour Hosting.com