I'm
currently only collecting one series of statues -
Batman: Black and White. I've been looking around for other goodies to
add to the mix lately, but nothing has really tripped my trigger.
But then I saw the Cover Girls of the DC Universe on display at last summer's
SDCC.
Being a red blooded breathing heterosexual male, my first thought was
"HOMINA, HOMINA, HOWWA!" And I didn't even know I could speak Cherokee.
(extra geek points for getting that pop culture reference.)
The
first release in the series is Black Canary, based on the artwork of
the talented Adam Hughes and sculpted by Jack Mathews. Actually, she's
been out for awhile, and I think Zatanna is out by now too - mine just
hasn't shown up yet.
It's considered
a "limited edition", although at 5000 pieces, that's stretching the
definition a bit. Compare that to an edition size of just 200 for Remy, and I think you'll
see my point.
They
have big plans for this series, and have already shown off Catwoman,
Wonder Woman, Power Girl, Harley and Zatanna. Word is Batgirl and
Supergirl are soon to be announced, and I suspect we'll see quite a
good set before this line finishes up.
These are done in a 9" scale, and
come in around $80 at most retailers. As usual, I have several great
suggestions in the Where to Buy section. Remember, these sponsors make
it possible to keep the site up and running, so please check them out.
Packaging - ***
It's a box, big surprise, and the solid interior trays keep the statue
and stand (they're separate pieces) very safe. The graphics are pretty
basic, and a window would give you the chance to see what you're
particular statue looks like, but I'm sure the logistics were a bit
much for them to work out.
They
have added in one of the DC Direct large style paper Certificates of
Authenticity. Mine ended up crinkled because they placed it on top
instead of on the side, and the COA is slightly bigger than the area of
the top, but hopefully they don't do that consistently across the
series.
Sculpting - ***1/2
Hiding beneath the paint (more on
that in a minute) is a very pretty lady. They've transcended the usual
comic book look, creating a more realistic version of the character in
a number of ways.
A lot of the credit for that
goes to the
stockings. These things look amazing, with a webbing that's perfectly
in scale with the 9" statue. You might still end up with the oversized
line up the back, but from the front and side they look great, and they
highlight the underlying sexy, muscled legs perfectly.
From the
neck down, the sculpt quality is excellent. I'm not thrilled with the
pose, but I'll bash on that in the Design section. While the statue is
based on Hughes' work, the breasts aren't the size of watermelons,
another feature far too often exploited when doing collectibles based
on these ladies. By not over emphasizing these proportions, they've
avoided looking too comic book, and allowed them to be somewhat more
like an actual woman. Or at least an actual fantasy woman.
From the neck up, there's a
couple issues though that pull the score
down. The hair is a bit too thick, lacking the kind of fine detail I
expect. The same is true with the skin itself, and unfortunately, the
paint doesn't help the situation. The teeth have no detail, and instead
are a solid white chunk inside her mouth. At this scale, these things
become obvious and distracting, making her look more Barbie doll than
high end statue. The lack of sculpted eyebrows also hurts, giving her
that 50's look where the eyebrows are completely plucked and repainted
on. I might understand it in a much smaller scale (although many of
DCUC women have sculpted eyebrows), but here it's not acceptable.
Paint - **
Again, from the neck up is where the problems lie, and this time the
problems are great enough to seriously effect the score.
From
the neck down, things are great. I love the contrast between the gloss
body suit and boots and the matte jacket, and the work on the gold
buckles on the boots is clean and neat. There's no slop, everything is
consistent and even, and there's not much you could improve upon.
However,
the work on the face and hair, clearly a key aspect, is not as good. I
think Hot Toys has pretty much ruined it for everyone, not just sixth
scale manufacturers, when it comes to sculpt and paint. If they can get
a photo-realistic sculpt and paint job on their figures, why can't
others do it on statues and busts? Yes, their figures are more
expensive...but include a ton of accessories, an articulated body, and
great costumes. With a statue and bust there really is only the paint
and sculpt that matter, so you'd think these things would get even more
attention.
The paint on the hair and face
is very toy-ish. In fact, I'd argue that the work on the DCUC wave 10 Power Girl
is far superior, considering the smaller scale.
The
eyebrows are painted on, as I mentioned in the previous section. The
eyes have a very doll-like appearance, and even the upper lip is uneven
and crooked. I understand that the price is lower here than usual, but
you can't skimp on the work on the face.
Design - ***
The design
of the statue - the selected pose, expression, and artistry - isn't a
surprise, since it's the same as what we saw back at SDCC. A weird
thing happens with me though, and perhaps it happens with you too. It's
one thing for me to see it at a show, or in a magazine, and quite
another to actually hold it in my hands. Especially after paying for it.
The
design was never something that stuck with me, which is the first sign
of trouble. A pose like the one they selected for Catwoman, now THAT
sticks with me, but this one left me with that old feeling of 'meh'.
In
hand, that translates into some level of disappointment. She's cracking
her knuckles, with her right foot extended off the floor. Something
about the overall pose just seems odd, and I think I probably could
have dealt with the outstretched hands if not for the odd foot position.
In
combination, they really don't do a lot for me. Now, I know that these
are based on actual cover art for these characters, so they probably
didn't have much to choose from for Black Canary. It's not the worst
pose ever, and from certain angles it works, but I can't help but think
there had to be a better choice than this.
Value - ***
Batman: Black and White statues are now running around $70 at most
retailers, and you can find this statue for under $80 pretty easily.
Considering the 30% larger size, that makes her (and the rest of the
series, if they stay in that range) a pretty good value in my book.
Things to Watch Out For -
With this kind of statue, it's always a good idea to be careful
inserting the metal posts into the base. She has two on her left foot
to keep her upright, and since metal will always win in a battle with
resin, you want to take some care.
The good news is that the fit is
just right, so that inserting and removing the posts poses less risk
than usual.
Overall - **1/2
I'm being a bit rough on this statue, but I'm hoping that we won't see
the same sort of paint work on the future statues. Perhaps if we all
bring it up early, they'll avoid it moving forward.
I'm
also not particularly keen on the selected pose. Again, that's an issue
I don't have with the other releases (well, most of them) shown so far.
I'll be continuing with the series, at least for now, but I certainly
hope that we see some paint quality improvements. I haven't seen
Zatanna yet, but I hear she's outstanding.
Related
Links -
If you're a fan of Black Canary, check out her 6" action figure version
from the DC Universe Classics line. DC Direct also did an earlier action figure,
back a few years ago.
Discussion:
Want to chat about this
review? Try out one of these terrific
forums where I'll be
discussing it!
Enjoyed this review? Be sure to head back to the main page to find
thousands more just like it!
Reader Ratings!
Here's your chance to weigh
in! Select your rating for this figure(s) to the
right.
Yea, it's a five star system and not a four star system like
mine,
but it's the best I've been able to come up with so far. You
can
only rate once from any particular IP. My score converted to
a five star system for comparison: 3.13