Packaging - **1/2
The packaging is attractive, but lacks one of my favorite things - any uniqueness from character to
character. They are all identical, although you can see the figure fairly clearly through the window. The window isn't huge though, and does block a fair amount of the figure.
These packages are huge too, taking up a ton of space. They are collector friendly, and you can certainly open them without any damage, but storing them in these boxes means using up a ton of space.
Sculpt - Ivy ***; Harley **
Asamiya is best known for his manga art. Therefore, it should be no
surprise that these two ladies look like they just stepped of the page of a
manga comic. The faces have that simple design, with large eye, round
faces, and tiny noses and lips.
I don't mind that - this is just another version of the old standby, and
it's good that they're different - but some folks will hate it.
My scores are lower not because of the style, but because the general
design of the statues is less than exciting.
Harley is the worse of the two. The base is very simple, and her
pose is not particularly dynamic. On top of that, it's an odd pose,
and I'm not quite sure what's up with her left arm. Is she reaching
for an arrow, forgetting that she skipped wearing her quiver today?
Maybe she had a sudden itch, or perhaps she's patting herself on the
back? Your guess is as good as mine.
Ivy has a better pose in general, and the amount of detail in her hair
and costume makes her the far more photogenic of the pair. She's
caressing her version of Audrey, and is clearly enjoying herself. The
plant seems pretty damn happy as well.
These figures have something in common with each other, and with the
Catwoman released in the first wave. Kia is clearly a man who knows
what a woman's butt should look like.
Paint - ***
The paint ops are above average, although not quite at the level I'd expect
from a $20 statue.
The lines are fairly clean, and the masking is good in most areas.
There's a nice choice of greens and browns on Ivy and her base, and the red
hair and white skin contrast extremely well. She does have a number of
stray paint marks on her torso though, and there are rub marks and scrapes
on both figures, indicating that the paint may not hold up well to handling
over time.
Articulation - *
These are statues, not action figures. However, I gave them a slight
score, because they do have pseudo-joints where some of the body parts
attach, like the arms. You can do some minor rearranging, but it's not
really articulation.
Accessories - Ivy **1/2; Harley **;
Each figure comes with one accessory - a display base.
Harley's is very basic, designed like one of those giant cookies you can
get made at the mall. It's a heart, with frosting and a symbol of the
love between HQ and the Joker.
Ivy's stand is much more interesting in terms of sculpt, paint and
design. It's much more visually appealing, and adds quite a bit to the
figure.
Unfortunately, neither stand works particularly well. I was
surprised, since all the Yamato figures I've bought up to this point
attached to the bases extremely well. That was not the case with
either of these lovely ladies. Neither foot peg/hole combo worked
well, and I tried a number of techniques to improve the situation, to no
avail. I got them to stay, but they didn't match up quite right, and
didn't fit as cleanly as you'd expect.
Fun Factor - *
Again, they're statues. You aren't going to have much 'fun' with them,
since they are intended to simply look good on the shelf.
Value - **
These are running even higher these days than past waves, as much as $18 - $20 each. The imported nature is driving this of course, but it's still well above the average price of a specialty market figure.
Things to watch out for -
If you have a choice, pick out the best paint application. The other
issues that these figures have will be consistent across them all, so
picking one over the other won't do you much good.
Overall - Ivy **1/2; Harley **
I'm glad I picked these up at the two-fer sale, and not at full
price. Neither blew my socks off, and had I spent $20 - or God forbid,
$25 - a piece for them, I would have been down right upset. I skipped
the Batmen simply because I have so many versions of him, but I may give
them a second look just to see if they are better than their lady
counterparts.
SCORE RECAP:
Packaging - **1/2
Sculpt - Ivy ***; Harley **
Paint - **1/2
Articulation - *
Accessories - Ivy **1/2; Harley **
Fun Factor - *
Value - **
Overall - Ivy **1/2; Harley **
Where to Buy -
You can find these at some specialty stores, like Media Play or your local comic shop - or try these online sponsors:
- Circle Red has this wave for just $65 for the full set of four, and the previous wave for just $60 for the full set of four.
- Time and Space Toys doesn't have this wave, but they have a great price on wave 1 at $60 for all four figures.
- CornerStoreComics has the full set for $70, or the individual figures for $18 each.
- Yikes Comics has the individuals for $19 each.
Related Links -
With a show like South Park, there's plenty of related links:
Here's some related links:
- Yamato has also done wave 1, wave 2
and wave 3 of their less manga-ized versions of Batman.
|