SEARCH      FEATURES    NEWSLETTER    EMAIL     HOME
White Space
Captain Toy/Michael's Review of the Week
Review Header Bar
White Space

The 2015 People's Picks - The Ballot!


Poppies 2015

Dividing Bar

Dividing Bar

Hello readers!  It's time for the 2015 People's Picks voting.  This is where you, the reader and collector, get to weigh in on the best collectibles of 2015, using the same exact ballot selections as the industry judges in the Poppies! It's always interesting to see how the general population of collectors votes in comparison to the judges, and I bet this year will prove particularly so.

The nominees on this ballot got here because of the judges. You can find the list of the 150 judges for 2015 right here. You'll see some very familiar names from companies large and small, media outlets around the net, retailers and collectors around the globe, and artists from many different areas. They discussed, argued and nominated those items they felt had that certain somethin' somethin' for each category.

NOTE: You only get to vote once, and the best way to control that is by asking for your email. If you want your vote to count, enter your email. I don't use the email addresses for anything else, including providing them to anyone for mail etc.

It is not necessary to vote in every category. I've included an 'abstain' button for each category which is the default (and very last) radio button. However, I've also provided links for all choices to refresh your memory on each nominee. Read through all the choices in each category before casting your vote, since what I call something might not be what you expected, and there are often two companies doing the same character or license. Thanks!

Let me know if you've got any questions by emailing me.  Thanks for your participation!   

Please share with your friends!

Enter your email:     

Dividing Bar

Best Overall Company: It's never easy to get this list pared down - there's just too many companies doing great work across the industry.

3A ACI Asmus Bandai/ Bandai Japan
Bif Bang Pow DC Collectibles Diamond Select Enterbay
Four Horsemen Funko Gentle Giant Hasbro
Hot Toys Jakks Jazwares Kotobukiya
LEGO Mattel McFarlane Toys Mezco
NECA Playmates Sideshow Star Ace
ThreeZero Weta ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Overall Line - High End: I'd like to change the name of this category, but I'm not sure what fits best.  I'm not interested in getting too specific with the 'rules' and nominators generally get the concept of high end versus low end, but I think there must be a better term to indicate it. Let me know if you have any suggestions!

There's a lot of very, very good nominees here, and there are some licenses shared by multiple companies, so please pay particularly close attention. The links are merely reminders, because you're voting for the entire line, not a single release.

Avengers Vignette, Dragon Models Batman (all lines), Hot Toys Batman Black/White, DC Collectibles Batman 1966, Tweeterhead
DC Bombshells, DC Collectibles DC Comics, Sideshow DC Comics, Kotobukiya Doctor Who, Big Chief
Gang's Kingdom, Dam Toys Harry Potter, Star Ace Hobbit/LOTR, Weta Manchester United, ZCWO
Marvel (all lines), Hot Toys Marvel ArtFX, Kotobukiya Marvel, Play Imaginative NBA, Enterbay
One:12 Collective, Mezco Star Wars Movie Realization, Bandai Star Wars, Egg Attack Star Wars, Hot Toys
Star Wars, S.H. Figurarts Star Wars, Sideshow Transformers Masterpiece, Hasbro/Takara Warframe, Symbiote Studios
ABSTAIN


Dividing Bar

Best Overall Line - Low End: Lots of great choices, some from the same license, so attention must be paid. Remember, the links here are just to remind you on the OVERALL line, not a specific figure or wave. You're voting for the overall line and what it did throughout the year, not a single release. Thanks!

Alien(s), NECA Barbie Spy Squad, Mattel Batman Animated, DC Collectibles Batman Designer Series, DC Collectibles
Femme Fatales, DST Firefly Legacy, Funko Game of Thrones, Dark Horse Ghostbusters, DST
Gotham Select, DST Jurassic World, Hasbro Marvel Legends, Hasbro Marvel Select, DST
Masters of the Universe Classics, Mattel Mortal Kombat, Mezco Pop!, Funko Reaction, Funko
Retro Figures (8inch cloth outfits), NECA Simpsons Celebrity Series, NECA Star Wars 4inch (5poa), Hasbro Star Wars Black (6inch), Hasbro
Star Wars Elite (diecast), Disney TMNT, Kid Robot TMNT, Playmates Transformers, Hasbro
Video Game Series, NECA Walking Dead, McFarlane WWE, Mattel ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Eddie Wires Award: The Eddie Wires Award for Outstanding Paint is intended to honor a collectible that stands out in the Paint Application category.

Balrog, Weta Bruce Lee Enter The Dragon, Enterbay Hulkbuster, ArtFX, Kotobukiya Iron Man MK43 1/4 scale, Hot Toys
Iron Man Whiplash II, Hot Toys Marilyn Monroe, Blitzway Panzier Cop, Hot Toys Rise of the Tomb Raider
Smaug, Weta ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Male Figure - 1/4 Scale and Above: While NECA tended to dominate this year with a lot of releases, a couple other well known companies did keep them honest with some great releases of their own.

Batman Arkham Knight, NECA Batman, Batman Begins, NECA Boba Fett, Hot Toys Darth Vader Battle Buddies, Hasbro
Devastator, Transformers Generations, Hasbro Hulkbuster Titan Series, Hasbro Iron man MK 43, Hot Toys Joker Dark Knight, NECA
Peguin, NECA Predator, NECA Robin 1966, NECA Superman, Chris Reeve, NECA
ABSTAIN


Dividing Bar

Best Male Figure - 12 - 17": This is usually the most controversial category, and we kept the nominations to a minimum this year, although there's tons and tons of great choices. And before you ask me why certain Hot Toys figures are on the ballot and others aren't, that's because I allow the company (as with all companies) final say in which ones they think best represent them.

Aragorn, ACI Aragorn, Asmus Darth Vader, Hot Toys Deadpool, Sideshow
Diamond 4, Gangs Kingdom, Dam Toys Han Solo in Hoth Gear, Sideshow Heisenberg, ThreeZero Luke Skywalker Tatooine, Hot Toys
Ned Stark, Game of Thrones, ThreeZero Robocop BD (Murphy), Hot Toys Scout Trooper, Sideshow Sirius Black, Star Ace
Whiplash MKII, Hot Toys ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Male Figure - 5" - 11": Another category with lots of good choices, and plenty of good choices that didn't make the ballot. There's always controversy around why did this Marvel Legends or Batman Animated figure get on and this one didn't, etc, but only so many can be on the ballot each year.

Antman (movie), Marvel Legends, Hasbro Batman Animated, DC Collectibles Batman DKR One:12 Collective, Mezco Boba Fett Ronin, Tamashii Nations Bandai
Bossk, Star Wars Black, Hasbro Callix MOTUC, Mattel Carnage, Marvel Select, DST Deathstroke, Arrow, DC Collectibles
Doctor Strange, Marvel Select, DST Iron Patriot, Play Imaginative Joker, Batman Animated, DC Collectibles King Choobla, MOTUC, Mattel
Kraven, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Malcolm Reynolds, Firefly Legacy, Funko Raiden, Mortal Kombat, Mezco Ray Stantz, Ghostbusters, DST
Rocketeer, Legacy, Funko Spider-Man, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Stan Lee, Celebrity Simpsons, NECA Stormtrooper First Order, Star Wars Black, Hasbro
Superior Venom, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Superman Chris Reeve, NECA Taylor, 8inch POTA, NECA Ultra Magnus, Transformers Generations, Hasbro
ABSTAIN


Dividing Bar

Best Male Figure - Under 5": There aren't as many nominees in this category these days. Part of that is due to the lack of G.I. Joe, part is due to the shift of Star Wars product shipping late in the year and more being held until 2016. It's also due to a lot of the movie licenses moving up to the 6" scale, abandoning the smaller size a bit. There's still some really good choices here, and a couple of them are well off the beaten path.

Carl, Walking Dead, McFarlane Collosus, Juggernaut version, Hasbro Cultist, Legends of Cthulhu, Warpo General Hux, Star Wars, Hasbro
Gung Ho, G.I. Joe, Hasbro Herschel, Walking Dead, McFarlane Korg, Marvel Infinite, Hasbro Rick Grimes, Walking Dead, McFarlane
Sherlock, Underground Toys Snowtrooper First Order, Star Wars, Hasbro Vision, Marvel Infinite, Hasbro ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Female Figure - Over 11": While the outside world has finally gotten hip to the smaller number of available female action figures, the number available has actually increased. We've got some excellent choices in every scale this year!

Black Widow, AoU, Hot Toys Eowyn, LOTR, Asmus Gamora, GotG, Hot Toys Haunted Zombie Bride, Barbie, Mattel
Hermione, Harry Potter, Star Ace Hit Girl, Medicom Lady Action, Captain Action Lady of the White Woods, Barbie, Mattel
Maria Hill, Avengers, Hot Toys Tauriel, Hobbit, Asmus ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Female Figure - 5" - 11": I'm pretty sure it's a rarity to have almost as many female figures in this category as male, and perhaps more surprising is that even without a large contingent of figures from lines like DCUC and MOTUC, this scale is booming.

Black Widow, Marvel Select, DST Canary, Arrow, DC Collectibles Captain Phasma, Star Wars Elite, Disney Captain Phasma, Star Wars Black, Hasbro
Gemma, Sons of Anarchy, Mezco Huntara, MOTUC, Mattel Maggie, Evolve Legacy, Funko Mara of Primus, MOTUC, Mattel
Maria Hill, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Misty Knight, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Nova, Heroes of the Storm, NECA Purple Power Ranger Dino Super Charge, Bandai
Rey, Star Wars Black, Hasbro Ripley, Aliens, NECA Roxy Rocket, Batman Animated, DC Collectibles Scarlet Witch, Marvel Legends, Hasbro
Selina Kyle, Gotham Select, DST Wasp, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Zoe, Firefly Legacy, Funko ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Female Figure - Under 5": As with the male figures, there were fewer lines in this scale during 2015, but Marvel and Star Wars provided some great options.

Ashoka Tano (adult), Star Wars, Hasbro Black Cat, Marvel Infinite, Hasbro Captain Phasma, Star Wars, Hasbro Card Captor Sakura, Max Factory
Carol, Walking Dead, McFarlane Emma Frost, Marvel Infinite, Hasbro Minnie Mouse (Ms. Cratchet), Disney Princess Leia Organa, Star Wars Black, Hasbro
Scarlet Witch, AoU, Hasbro Shanna, Marvel Infinite, Hasbro ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Build a Figure: I don't think it takes a great prognosticator to tell Hasbro will win this one this year, but for what series? Next year we already know Mattel will be on the ballot as well, so the concept isn't going any where any time soon.

Allfather, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Build a Weapon, Star Wars, Hasbro Defensor, Transformers, Hasbro Hobgoblin, Marvel Legends, Hasbro
Hulkbuster, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Menasor, Transformers Generations, Hasbro Rhino, Marvel Legends, Hasbro Thanos, Marvel Legends, Hasbro
Ultron, Marvel Legends, Hasbro ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Play Set or Vehicle: This is one of the few categories that always sports a tremendous amount of variety in style, price range, and design. There's a couple of the same items from different manufacturers nominated this year, so pay extra attention.

Bat (The) DKR, Hot Toys Batcave 1966, Mattel Batmobile, BTAS, DC Collectibles Batmobile, DKR, Dragon
Bat Signal set, DKR, Hot Toys Deadluxe High School, Monster High, Mattel First Order Snowspeeder, Star Wars, Hasbro Giant Leonardo Play Set, TMNT, Playmates
Iron Man MKIII Construction Dio, Hot Toys Law Giver, POTA, NECA Power Loader, Aliens, NECA Rey's Speeder, Star Wars FA, Hasbro
Roxy Rocket, Batman Animated, DC Collectibles Speederbike, Star Wars, Sideshow Talon Fighter, MOTUC, Mattel Tardis, Doctor Who, Funko
Taun Taun, Star Wars Black, Hasbro Taun Taun, Star Wars, Sideshow TIE Fighter, Star Wars Black, Hasbro ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Statue: Plenty to chose from here, and quite a wide variety of licenses and styles as well.

Balrog, Weta Batman, 1966, Tweeterhead Batman Returns PF, Sideshow Black Widow, XM Studios
Bruce Lee, Enter the Dragon, Blitzway Catwoman, 1966 Newmar, Tweeterhead Eddie Munster, Tweeterhead Hawkgirl, Bombshells, DC Collectibles
Hulk, AoU, Dragon Hulkbuster, Dragon Hulkbuster, Kotobukiya Jean Gray Phoenix, XM Studios
Marilyn Monroe, Blitzway Metroid Samus, First 4 Figures MGSV Snake, Gecco Pinhead PF, Sideshow
Rise of the Tomb Raider Rocket and Groot, Gentle Giant Sentinel, Marvel, Sideshow She-Hulk (red SDCC), Kotobukiya
Smaug, Hobbit, Weta Superman, DC Super Powers, Kotobukiya Target, Munky King Warframe Rhino, Symbiote Studios
ABSTAIN


Dividing Bar

Best Bust: Wow - fewer bust nominees than BAF nominees. The times they are a changing. At least we see a nice variety here from 1/6th scale to 1/4 scale to full size.

Akuma, Pop Culture Shock Catwoman 1966, DST Dark Knight Batman, Sideshow Harley Quinn, BTAS, DST
Iron Man MK43, Hot Toys Marv, Sin City, DST Smaug, Hobbit, Weta War Machine MK2, Iron Man, Hot Toys
ABSTAIN


Dividing Bar

Best Designer/Vinyl: I think the judges did a nice job this year coming up with a good selection, covering both mass market and specialty market releases.

Abominable Snow Cone, Monster Toys Avengers Hero Remix, Dragon Cthulhu, DST DC Heroes/Hello Kitty remix, Dragon
Four Horsies of the Pocalypse, Bigshot Toyworks Hulkbuster Cosbaby, Hot Toys Jaws Shark, Funko Kevin Smith Podcast Pals SDCC Vinylmate, DST
Lil Mikey, TMNT, Mondo MOTUSCLE, Super7 Mr. Pumpfrey, Munky King Rocket, Vinyl Suger, Funko
Tony Stark (Mark XLIII Armor Version) Artist Mix Designed by TOUMA, Hot Toys Trouble Trouble, Munky King ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Prop Replica: One theme for this year's replicas - stuff I never thought would get made! The bolt from Iron Giant? An actual Halo motorcycle helmet? The actual USA Today doing their own BTTF cover? There were some big surprises this year...along with some tried and true recipes as well.

Batman's Cowl, Arkham Origins, TriForce Bilbo's Pipe, Weta Black Arrow, Hobbit, Weta Bolt, Iron Giant, Mondo
Captain America's Shield, eFX Captain America's Shield (BD), Lager Elvira Dagger, Tweeterhead HALO Master Chief Motorcycle Helmet, NECA
Kylo Ren FX Lightsaber, Hasbro Mr. Fusion, DST USA Today Cover Page, BTTF ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

Best Building Set/Mini Figures: Last year we altered this category to be more specific and select the actual series or set. Some of these are quite specific, others much more general. Hey, it's not an exact science, but there's lots of good choices!

Aliens, Mini-mates, DST Big Bang Theory,Lego Call of Duty, Megabloks DC Superheroes, Lego
Doctor Who, Lego Elves, Lego Game of Thrones, McFarlane G.I. Joe Terrordrome, Kre-O
Halo, MegaBloks Marvel Superheroes, Lego Marvel Minimates, DST Minions, MegaBloks
Scooby Doo, Lego Star Wars, Lego Walking Dead, McFarlane Wall-E, Lego
ABSTAIN


Dividing Bar

Best Misc: Here's that catch all for the weird but wonderful oddities of the year. I find it interesting that there are two different T-Rex's on here...I call that the Jurassic World effect.

Alien Egg Carton, NECA Batmobile 1966 Bottle Opener, DST Extreme T-Rex, Imaginext Hero Mashers, Hasbro
Indominus Rex, Zoomer Red Queen Mother Alien, NECA Space Walls, GTP Toys ABSTAIN

Dividing Bar

And there you have it - once you have your ballot completed with your choices, just hit the Vote button below - thanks!

Dividing Bar

Dividing Bar

Thanks for all your help with this year's voting and awards! Remember, any questions please drop me an email.

Please share with your friends!


Back to Main Page

White Space
Review Bottom Edge
This page copyright 2000 - 2016, Michael Crawford. All rights reserved. Click here for copyright permissions!