The 2007 Poppies - the RESULTS!
In a season where other awards shows have been canceled or
turned into a mere shadow of themselves due to the writer's strike, the
Poppies march on!
If you haven't been following along, the Poppies are my new
industry based yearly awards. A panel of elite judges from the
industry, including representatives from
Companies, Artists, Retailers, Websites and Collectors, came together to
first nominate and then select the very best pop culture collectibles in ten
different categories. That process is now complete, and the winners
If you'd like a reminder on the list of Nominees, check out
the original Ballot page. And as you also remember, there's a contest
for the readers that ties into this, and I'll be drawing the name of the
winner from those that guessed the most correct matches this weekend.
And just to let you know, I've already picked my bests for
2007, so the results here won't have any influence. It is surprising
to see compare them though - I should have my bests and worst's up this
So let's have no further delays, and get right to the
Best Overall Company:
Since about 20% of the judges actually worked for the companies being
voted on, I expected this category to have the widest spread. It
doesn't help that the category also had the most nominations, to allow for a
dark horse to appear.
Neither of those things happened. While there were 38
companies that the judges could have chosen from, and while more than 20
different companies were represented in the Company judges, the three top
vote getters took almost 70% of the overall vote. These three are the
Which one was the very best was decided by only a vote or
two, so it was neck and neck between them. The third place finisher
was Hasbro, which is probably not surprising with their strong
continued support of the Star Wars line. While they might do a lot wrong,
they still have a tremendous amount of fan support for the 3 3/4" line.
The second place winner was Hot Toys. I said a
dark horse didn't appear, but that might just be because I've witnessed an
awful lot of love this year for their work, and if you haven't been paying
attention to the sixth scale market, that might be a surprise to you.
But they've come a tremendously long way over the last 18 months, and are
going to give every other company a real run for the top spot in '08.
And while it was close, I wasn't surprised to see
Sideshow take the top honors. They had a good year with several
lines, they made some excellent decisions around importing Hot Toys and
Medicom, and they continued to provide excellent customer service and
Best Overall Line:
There were a lot of terrific lines this year, which is a bit of a surprise
since the market has been so much tighter. The trick is that while
there are far fewer lines in total (especially with fewer new off the wall
lines), the quality of the ones that were produced was generally high.
I kept the nominations to the top 15 though, to avoid spreading the vote too
Often times, best company and best line go hand in hand,
much like best director and best film. That was the case with third
place, which went to Hasbro's Star Wars line. There were plenty
of things people liked about the line this year, including the McQuarrie
concept figures and some of the really AMAZING sculpting, paint and
articulation that was included with figures like Bossk. Hasbro seems
intent on raising the bar in this scale.
Second place also went to one of the Overall Company
winners, Sideshow, for their Star Wars line. While they had
their share of complaints, this year certainly had a number of very strong
figures in the series, including Obi-wan, the Rebel Troopers and Asajj.
The winner of the category is another reason why Hasbro
placed high in best company - the 25th Anniversary G.I. Joes.
While it's still not perfect or universally loved, it looks like Hasbro has
finally hit on a reboot of the classic that is resonanting with many
Best Figure 18" or over (Both Male and Female):
There were so few large scale figures this year, that I lumped both the male
and female versions together in one category. Also, this did not
include Premium Format style mixed media statues, as these are in a price
and quality range that puts them more in line with the Statue category.
NECA was the only company doing much work in this area this
year, so they dominated the nominations. Their Michael Myers, based on
the Rob Zombie film, took the third place honors, while they're updated Jack
Sparrow based on At World's End snagged the number two spot.
the number one winner by a landslide was Hasbro's Ultimate Bumblebee.
I bought one of these for my son for Christmas, and I can attest to just how
damn cool this Transformer is. I don't have any photos of it...but
it's damn cool!
Best Male Figure (12" - 18"):
These are really sixth scale figures, and some might be a little under 12"
tall because some companies just like to make their stuff an odd size...
The third place winner was a bit of a surprise for me - it's
Jabba the Hutt from Sideshow. Oh, it's not that I don't think
he's terrific, but rather that he's not a traditional sixth scale style
figure, and I thought that might hurt him in the voting. Apparently, I
Second place wasn't a surprise, with the votes going to
Medicom's Boba Fett. There were small issues here and there
with the figure that allowed us nit pickers to have our fun, but overall
it's a terrific figure.
And the big winner was no surprise to me either - Hot Toys
Endoskeleton. This guy is a an engineering marvel, and well
worth the high price.
Best Male Figure Under 12:
This was one of the more crowded categories, but the three top vote getters
managed to put a fair amount of distance between themselves and the rest of
Hasbro gets another medalist in the results with the third
place going to the Deluxe Concept Bumblebee. The Transformers
line is one of the most successful movie related lines in years, and I'm
betting we see the toys on the pegs for quite some time to come.
Second place went to a Build A Figure: the exceptional
Pitt from the first Legendary Comic Book Heroes line. While this
line is unlikely to be very successful in terms of pure sales, it's clearly
a big hit with critics and fans, and Pitt was a fantastic BAF.
The big winner is one that I could have almost predicted the
first time I saw him - Clayface from Mattel. The Four Horsemen
really hit this one out of the park, and he was a great lead in and
transition figure to the new DC Universe Classics line.
Best Female Figure (any size):
Again, there were simply so few female figures this year that I lumped the
poor ladies all into one category.
Still, I was expecting more variety in the results than we
got. I know I picked figures in more than one scale and style for my
top three, but the larger judges pool were big on the larger ladies this
Third place went to Elizabeth Swann from Hot Toys.
Personally, I thought she was the nicest sixth scale female of the year, so
I'm not surprised she ended in the top three at all.
Second place went to a big surprise for me - DC Direct's 13"
Deluxe Batgirl. This was not a figure I was particularly
enamored with, although she does show improvement for the deluxe line.
Still, the judges loved her, and they can't all be wrong.
The big winner is Asajj Ventress from Sideshow. While
she wouldn't be my top pick, I can certainly understand why she was.
Both head sculpts looked terrific, the Sideshow female body showed real
improvement with her release, and she's a bad girl. We all love bad
When you think statues, you think big, expensive and high quality. Of
course, not all of them are, but the winners this year certainly fit that
The third place winner here is one I really wish I'd bought.
It's the Premium Format Hulk from Sideshow, who really puts the
concept of 'mixed media' to the test, since it's just his tattered pants
that make him a PF. But he is truly an amazing looking statue, well
worth his price.
There's a tie for second, a rarity across all ten
categories. Two ladies took the second place trophy with the exact
same number of votes - Gentle Giant's Slave Leia and Sideshow's Mary Jane.
What I find most interesting about these two is that BOTH of them were at
the center of some controversy over their depiction of women. Perhaps
the fact that they were so well done is why the controversy existed.
The winner was no surprise to me - Sideshow's Premium Format
Captain America. This was a PF that received tons of kudos when it was
released, and really shows off how well the mixed media format can be
applied with the right character.
Guess what - Gentle Giant dominated the nominations this year. That should
be no surprise considering the quality Harry Potter, Star Wars and Lord of
the Rings busts they produced.
I think that caused them some trouble though when it came to
picking THE best. People were more spread out in this category than
any other, largely because there were plenty of good choices.
This wide spread caused a three way tie for third place, all
within GG's own product. The light up Ringwraith, the exclusive
Commander Cody, and the terrific Mad Eye Moody mini-busts all
received an equal number of third place votes.
Gentle Giant took second as well with their Darth Maul,
another great Star Wars addition.
But this spread of great choices, especially with many GG
busts, is perhaps why the winner was not a GG bust, but rather the DC
Direct Batgirl from the Women of the DC Universe. Or it could
simply be because she's knock out gorgeous!
This was a tough category. As popular as this area is, there is less
consistency and agreement, even to what constitutes the category.
But the judges were still able to do their job in nominating
and then voting. Third place went to Bart Simpson from Qee.
I think he's pretty nifty myself, and a nice marriage of licensed property
yet something that can be customized and personalized by any artist.
We had another of those ties for second place here, with
both the very cool Gorillaz and the rare Walter (The Big
Lebowski) taking an equal number of votes. I can't say much about
Walter, as I've only seen photos, but the Gorillaz are certainly well done.
The first place winner though had quite a few more votes
than those behind him. The Medicom VCD Yoda is very well loved
by Star Wars fans, and fits in terrific with the sixth scale line.
Let's hope the Ewok turns out as well, depending of course on your feelings
toward Ewoks in general.
And that brings us to our last category. Miscellaneous was intended to
catch the cornucopia of goodies that came out that really didn't fit any
where else. Pretty much the definition of the word, right?
The third place winner was the Master Replica's uber
expensive yet uber cool Millennium Falcon. Who didn't see this
guy in person and wish they had a) the cash to afford it or b) the place to
It was a good year for the Falcon too, and the Lego
version took second place. My son hasn't asked me for this yet,
and considering how many pieces there are, I'm thanking God.
Anything could have been nominated by the judges for this
category, so I had no idea what might end up on the ballot. But once
the ballot had been developed, I had absolutely no doubt what would win, and
it did: the Aliens Power Loader from Hot Toys. Oh, it's got a
few issues here and there, but this is another home run from Hot Toys in a
year where they made some truly remarkable products.
And there you have it - the first annual Poppies! I'd
like to thank all the judges for their contribution and assistance, and the
readers for playing along. I'm looking to continue this tradition in
the coming years, and I'll be looking for judges for next year, so if you or
someone you know would like to be involved, drop me a line!